Case Law
Federal Court Orders IRCC to Finalize Start-Up Visa Application Amidst 'Open-Ended Delay'

Federal Court Orders IRCC to Finalize Start-Up Visa Application Amidst 'Open-Ended Delay'

Application for Judicial Review Granted
Citation
2026 FC 1370
Decided
Court file
IMM-17672-25
Full judgment
Read the decision

Case Law Overview

NAGHAVI v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370

The Applicant sought a writ of mandamus to compel a final decision on his Start-up Visa (SUV) permanent residence application, submitted in March 2021. Despite being ready for finalization in June 2024, the application was subjected to an inordinate and open-ended delay caused by two successive Ministerial Instructions (MIs) that repeatedly deprioritized his file.

Court Ruling

The Federal Court granted the application, ordering the government to render a decision within 90 days. The Court found that the delay was unreasonable and that the Ministerial Instructions, which were the direct cause of the open-ended delay, could not serve as a satisfactory justification for it.

Key Quote from the Court

In the present case, the Minister has advanced two sets of MIs as justifications for the delay. I have determined that the MIs have been the perpetrators rather than the justification for open-ended delay. It is circular reasoning to accept the cause of open-ended delay as the justification for open-ended delay. (at para 42)

Expert Takeaways

  • Ministerial Instructions Are Not a Blank Cheque for Delay While the Minister has the authority to issue MIs to manage application processing, this power is not absolute. If MIs create an 'open-ended' and inordinate delay, the Court may not accept them as a reasonable justification.
  • The Cause of Delay Cannot Be Its Own Justification This decision powerfully rejects 'circular reasoning.' The government cannot use a policy instrument (like an MI) that is the very cause of an unreasonable delay as the legal excuse for that same delay.
  • Uncertainty Strengthens a Mandamus Case A key factor in the Court's decision was the lack of a realistic processing estimate for the applicant. Being deprioritized multiple times without a clear timeline creates the 'open-ended delay' that justifies a mandamus order.
  • Mandamus Remains a Powerful Tool Against Systemic Delays The Court affirmed that as long as IRCC keeps an application in the processing queue, it has a duty to process it reasonably. Mandamus is available to enforce this duty, regardless of whether the delay is caused by MIs or other administrative issues.

How long is too long?

There is no deadline to bring a mandamus application - and no fixed number of months that makes a delay unlawful. The Federal Court asks whether the delay is longer than the process reasonably requires, whether you have already asked for a decision and given the department a fair chance to make one, and whether the explanation offered for the wait actually holds up. The published processing time for your application type is where that comparison starts.

Does this ruling apply to your situation?

Tick whatever is true for you. Nothing is sent anywhere - this stays in your browser.

Disclaimer

The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Immigration law is complex and subject to change. For advice specific to your situation, please schedule a consultation with a qualified legal professional.

Refused again after reconsideration?

The Federal Court can still review your case — let's talk about your options.

Book a Consultation Contact Us

No obligation - we review your documents and tell you if a Federal Court application is realistic.

Questions people ask after reading a case like this

How long is too long before I can go to court?

There is no fixed number in the legislation. The Federal Court asks whether the delay is longer than the process reasonably requires and whether the department has a satisfactory justification for it. The published processing time for your application type is the usual starting point for that comparison - but it is a benchmark, not a legal deadline.

Is there a filing deadline for a mandamus application?

No. Mandamus concerns a decision that has not been made, so the 15-day and 60-day limits that apply to challenging a refusal do not apply here. Delay in bringing the application is still something the Court can weigh, so waiting indefinitely is not cost-free.

Do I have to ask IRCC for a decision first?

Normally yes. One of the requirements is a prior demand for the decision and a reasonable time for the department to respond. Keeping a record of your requests and the replies you received matters, because that correspondence is part of what the Court looks at.

What does the Court actually order if I win?

Mandamus does not decide your application and it does not order an approval. Where the requirements are met, the Court orders the department to make a decision, usually within a set period. The decision itself can still go either way.

Will going to court hurt my application?

Officers are required to decide each application on its merits. Asking the Court to compel a decision does not change the legal test that is applied to your file.

Ali Dadkhah

Written by

Ali Dadkhah

Ali Dadkhah is a litigator whose practice is dedicated to challenging government decisions at the Federal Court of Canada. He specializes in judicial review, providing a crucial avenue for recourse for individuals and businesses who have faced unfair or unreasonable administrative outcomes. Bilingual legal support in English and Persian (Farsi)

Stay informed

Follow Ali Dadkhah on LinkedIn

Visa or PR refused? Stuck for years? We challenge IRCC at the Federal Court - judicial review & mandamus.

Follow on LinkedIn